Roses on February 14? The aberrant carbon footprint of their industrial production

Lets stop the roses for Valentines Day by Bruno Parmentier

The French are preparing to offer 1.5 million plants and bouquets of flowers this weekend on the occasion of Valentine’s Day, an extremely important day for florists, one of the only days of the year when flowers are bought en masse. This could be an opportunity to also think about the planet we want to build.

For once, on the occasion of this yet significant act, let’s think a little about the world we want to build and realize: when we buy a product, we also buy the world that goes with it!

When you don’t know how to choose, you are often tempted by the superb roses that florists offer us in abundance! Above all, with the symbolism of colors, what better than to offer a huge bouquet of red roses that will know better than to translate our feelings of love. How many roses will leave this weekend? About 50 million! They will be present in half of the bouquets.

But by the way, have you seen blooming roses in February in France? Giving roses on February 14 is a bit like giving cherries or strawberries, they necessarily come from very far away, and in addition, as they are perishable products, they came by plane! In the strict sense, they perfume… the kerosene our beautiful roses bred near airports in Kenya, Ethiopia, South Africa, Ecuador or even in China, in social conditions that one can imagine to be very bad!

And of course without skimping on pesticides, many of which are banned in Europe, because who can believe that these sanitized and gigantic roses, with a single stem, which support a transport of thousands of kilometers, have not been abused, tampered with, boosted, artificialized as much as possible? Some others come from Dutch greenhouses heated and lit 20 hours a day, made from coal or of gas well polluting, or, at best, toenergy nuclear ! Not to mention the successive transports, most often by truck, from Holland where they all passed anyway. Because of course, the 15% of French flowers sold in France are almost all, too, passed through Amsterdam.

Is this the planet we want?

A planet where to offer a simple bouquet of 15 roses, we emit as many greenhouse gas than a journey of 200 kilometers in car ?

Let’s not be a killjoy, nothing prevents you from offering flowers to your beauty to show that, despite everything, especially in this particularly difficult year because of the Covid-19 pandemic, we are still capable of love and gratuitous acts. But, even if there are practically no more French cut flowers (the profession has fallen from 30,000 to only 3,000 jobs), we still have a magnificent ornamental horticulture sector, which still accounts for 160,000 jobs, which have been greatly abused for two years due to confinements. We therefore have an excellent opportunity to show that we want to pollute the planet less and more social solidarity in our country, which would add a lot of meaning to our gift of love!

There is no shortage of more ecologically correct ideas: camellias, tulips, amaryllisiris, crocus, jasmine, Mimosaanemones, buttercups, wallflowers, freesias, cyclamen, primroses, daffodils, etc.

And why not, for our pleasure to be complete, also use the short circuit and aim for labels like blue plant, which guarantees that the plants have been produced in an eco-responsible manner by horticulturists or certified nurseries, Flower of France which guarantees the French origin of the plants, Fairtrade Max Havelaar Where Fair Flowers Fair Plantsfor fair trade flowers produced in compliance with environmental and social standards.

And to go further, we can watch the excellent report broadcast on Monday February 7, 2022 on France 5 in replay: “ Valentine’s Day: what’s behind our bouquets? He shows the world that goes with the flowers of our florists (sold without indication of origin), and makes us understand that these are now hyper-industrial and globalized products. We discover in particular the covered market of Aalsmeer near Amsterdam, which alone occupies an area equivalent to that of the Vatican to process 12 billion flowers per year, but also the nearby greenhouses lit 20 hours a day and of which the energy consumption is equivalent to a city of 30,000 inhabitants.

And the industrial production of roses in Ethiopia, in greenhouses that produce 3 million flowers a day, which leave immediately by plane to Amsterdam. Flowers treated with around forty chemicals, several of which are strictly prohibited in Europe (do not touch or smell them too much, or throw them in your compost !).

Happy Valentine’s Day to all, with flowers that mean many things, starting with respect for the planet and the living!

Interested in what you just read?

fs11