Pia Shurjoka Scholz has been confronted with criticism and malicious comments in the German Twitch scene for many months. One of her critics is Tobias Huch, against whom she has now successfully obtained an injunction in court.
There have been tensions between Pia Shurjoka Scholz and Tobias Huch for a long time. Some streamers, YouTubers and content creators such as Scurrows, KuchenTV, MontanaBlack88 and Tobias Huch keep shooting against the streamer.
The fact that Shurjoka found herself in the crosshairs of various influencers and opinion bloggers began with her being named Player of the Year 2023. That was in May 2023. Since then, hundreds of videos have been created on YouTube that position themselves against Shurjoka.
more on the subject
Shurjoka in the crosshairs: How a 25-year-old activist became a hate figure on the Internet
from MeinMMO
In recent months, Tobias Huch has repeatedly made critical comments about Shurjoka and published a considerable number of reaction videos in which she was featured prominently in the thumbnail and her name appeared in the title.
Shurjoka was now able to have an injunction against YouTuber and FDP politician Tobias Huch enforced in court.
This is the court order: Shurjoka announced on
The streamer also writes:
[…] He is obliged to remove and refrain from the affected videos, streams, tweets and other posts as they are illegal.
Pia Shurjoka Scholz on X Shurjoka wins case: preliminary injunction against Tobias Huch
Shurjoka continued to explain on Because there is the possibility of turning to the next higher authority – the Frankfurt am Main Higher Regional Court. As Shurjoka emphasizes, she was able to enforce all injunction claims filed against Tobias Huch in proceedings last week.
The streamer has not yet announced what injunctive relief is involved in detail.
The court decision obliges Tobias Huch to refrain from making the statements listed in the injunction and to remove videos, streams, tweets and other posts that contain these statements because they have been classified as unlawful.
You can see her X thread about it here:
This is what Tobias Huch says about the verdict: The YouTuber emphasized on He will examine the issue extensively and contact the Frankfurt Higher Regional Court. The written decision was not shared publicly.
According to Tobias Huch, the process was about:
Specifically, it was about my criticism of her regarding her behavior towards the Jewish influencer der_aqeualist. I was temporarily (!) prohibited from making a statement. Shurjoka is welcome to post what was actually banned.
Tobias Cheers to X
Shurjoka responded to TikTok influencer and YouTuber The Equalist in a stream in September 2023. She saw videos of her (via X) in which extremely problematic takes on slavery and the relativization and associated trivialization of the Holocaust were expressed.
Shurjoka later apologized for her tone towards The Equalist on
Tobias Huch has also set up a donation page on which he also addresses the dispute:
[…] Or be it a Shurjoka who, with her toxic bubble, causes damage to opinion YouTubers – whose opinions she doesn’t like – when she tries to cancel them. For example, the streamer KuchenTV was recently blocked on Twitch after she attacked his Twitch account on Twitter. The mass reports led to his ban. Shurjoka has currently identified me as an opponent and is suing me because she doesn’t like what I’m saying about her after she spread about the Jewish influencer “The Aequalist” that she would relativize the Holocaust. She sees my comments as inadmissible. My lawyers and I see it differently. In the end, the courts will have to decide. The next instance is the Frankfurt Higher Regional Court. […]
Tobias Huch via gofundme What exactly is in the interim injunction is not entirely clear
In a reply to Tobias Huch’s X-Post, Shurjoka writes that his claim is not true.
She says:
[…] The injunction says something completely different. You have it before you? Why are you saying something here that is factually incorrect?
You received a decision because you spread abusive criticism that violated personal rights.
Shurjoka via X
She then shared a list showing the number of Tobias Huch’s videos about her (at that point). You can see the list here:
Following the decision, Tobias Huch uploaded a video about Shurjoka today, March 8, 2024. These reaction videos and others from other streamers and YouTubers such as KuchenTV and Scurrows have regularly brought her into the center of attention.
More on the topic: Shurjoka in the crosshairs: How a 25-year-old activist became a hate figure on the Internet